"Extremely disappointed. I went by others people reviews, only to find a sandwich with tiny pieces of sausage thrown in with feta cheese and ricotta cheese not melted so that the sausage and cheese rolled out. Extremely salty which I knew due to the sausage and cheese however they just threw it in the bread Their coffee was delicious as well as their freshly squeezed orange juice, but i wouldn't order again. Their home fries were basic with not much taste but pepper."

"this has to be the worst bait and switch. ordered a pistachio cake for a birthday and it came completely different from what piece of cake has posted on the website. it looks like slimer threw up on it and it tasted similar with this gelled nickelodeon slime on it. definitely not trusting them with another important event unless its a kids Minecraft party."

"I decided to try this place as I live pretty close by and a neighbor of mine was talking it up. Absolutely delicious and staff was so friendly. My knee is not good and they made something that is usually a hassle enjoyable and easy. Allie which is one of the workers was helpful and nice making this an overall 10/10 experience. Food was great (i got the zucchini frittata). Wish I took some pictures but It was so delicious I couldn’t put it down."

"I tried the strawberry cake from Piece A Cake and it was absolutely amazing! 🍓 The flavor was fresh, rich, and perfectly balanced — not too sweet, just right. You can really taste the quality and care that goes into their baking. The texture was super soft and moist, and the presentation looked beautiful too. Definitely one of the best cakes I’ve had on Staten Island. Highly recommend this place for anyone who loves great desserts and friendly service! 🎂👏"

"Dropped by simply because my boy toddler lovessss the crane outside and was fully surprised to see more fun stuff inside! Not only is the antique feels fun for the kiddos, but their cakes are delicious! I have had such a hard time trying to find light, not overly sugary sweet, cakes on the island that I’ve gotten a little scared. Piece of Cake gave out a sample (which we are still trying to figure out what it was!) during the Christmas Tree lighting and it was so yum that we now go almost every week to try a new pastry and to figure out the mystery pastry during the Christmas tree lighting! The creams are seriously so yummy and not too sweet, and prices are great! Piece of Cake absolutely won our hearts and approval!"