"Gelaterra is an absolute gem in Staten Island! The gelato here is so fresh, creamy, and full of flavor—it’s honestly the best I’ve had. Every flavor I’ve tried has been amazing, but the Pistachio is hands-down my favorite. It’s perfectly nutty, rich, and not overly sweet. You can really taste the quality ingredients and care they put into every scoop. Whether you’re a gelato lover or just looking for a sweet treat, Gelaterra is a must-visit spot. I can’t wait to go back and try more flavors!"

"Five stars are not enough! This Staten Island gelato shop is airy, spacious, welcoming, and refined. The ice cream? Very tasty, smooth and wonderfully, brutally cold. If I lived in Staten Island, I would be here every day. Since I do not, I can only make sure to visit every time I am in the borough."

"Gelaterra is such a cozy spot — I love the atmosphere, it’s super laid-back and welcoming. One thing I really appreciate is that they stay open late. It’s so nice to be able to grab an iced matcha after 6 pm when most other places are already closed. I’ve tried the pistachio and chocolate hazelnut gelato, and both were seriously delicious. You can tell they use good ingredients — the flavors are rich and the texture is super creamy. It’s definitely become one of my go-to places for a treat or a little evening break."

"My visit to Gelaterra was a complete impulse decision and I am so glad that I went. This place is amazing. The Gelato is soooooo good! I don’t think I’ve ever had some of those flavors and they were fantastic. Smooth, creamy, and soooooo delicious. The service was amazing as well. Santiago was my server and he was so nice and patient with me while I decided which flavors to chose. He was just a sweet guy! Pun intended. The place itself was clean and quiet and well presented. There was no confusion on flavors, drinks were clearly displayed and the entire cafe sitting area was clean and comfortable. 10/10 would go back and try more! Can’t wait."

"Cute place to relax and have some coffee or ice cream! They also have books and toys for the kids while you enjoy your ice cream or coffee. Very clean and friendly!"