"We really enjoyed our visit to Amity Coffee! The ambiance is welcoming and friendly, the staff is polite and courteous, and the selection of food and beverages were all delicious! We tried the Matcha latte, the Cappuccino, the avocado toast, the Butter Croissant, the Chocolate Croissant, the Chipotle Breakfast Bowl, the Lemon Poppy Muffin, and enjoyed everything a lot. The croissants were nice and flaky, the pickled onions in the Breakfast Bowl and Avocado Toast were excellent, and the latte art on the Matcha Latte were notable highlights! Highly recommend!"

"Great little coffee joint. Pour overs were delish, cappuccino too! Saturday morning in late Sept had a line out the door. Still service was efficient and friendly."

"I'm not a coffee drinker, so I can't speak to the quality of the coffee. However, I ordered an earl grey that ended up tasting more like hot water and milk (even after letting it steep for 10 minutes). The other tea I had was slightly better, but it seems weird that with such a huge bag of tea that the flavor would take a while to get flavor. We also got a few pastries, but the only one that I liked was the croissant. Thats not to say everything was bad. My friend liked the coffee and the atmosphere was nice. Overall, I wouldnt come back though"

"My lovely employers sent me coffee from your store all the way to the Philippines, and I must say—the coffee is refreshingly aromatic! It's truly a memorable coffee-sipping experience!”"

"First time stopping here in downtown Penn Yan and we were not disappointed! What a cool little place to enjoy some coffee. We stopped in mid afternoon and there were just a few people chilling out on laptops. Very comfortable seating and clean. The coffee was awesome and enjoyable. Highly recommend a stop when in the area."