"> I stopped by this café in Middletown and immediately fell in love — it’s absolutely a hidden jewel and truly a must-visit. The space is cozy, charming, and welcoming from the moment you walk in. They offer an amazing selection of coffee, freshly baked goods, delicious sandwiches, and refreshing juices — there’s something for everyone. > I tried the vegan coquito coffee, a juice, and a sandwich because I genuinely wanted to experience as much as possible to give an honest and thoughtful review, and everything was outstanding. Each item was made with care and full of flavor. > What really makes this café special is the sense of family you feel throughout the space. The warmth of Puerto Rican hospitality is present in every detail, and it truly makes you feel at home. The owner is incredibly welcoming, kind, and humble, which adds so much heart to the experience. > I wish this beautiful establishment nothing but prosperity and continued success — I’ll definitely be returning and recommending it to others. Definitely worth the 2 hour drive. @Café Con Amor Jíbaro #cafecito #cafepr #orgullopuertoriqueño🇵🇷🇵🇷🇵🇷🇵🇷 #jibaro #nycafedestinations"

"Their is a New hidden gem 💎 in the middletown area called Cafe Con Amor Jibaro 🇵🇷☕️ location on North Street. offering a taste of Puerto Rico with items like coffee frappes, pan sobao, and sandwiches,Authentic Puerto Rican Coffee the beans are from Tres Picachos in Jayuya, their Don Jose roast.Sourced directly from farms in Puerto Rico, ensuring a direct-from-the-farm experience. I am not a coffee 🇵🇷☕️ person but I had their coquito coffee i can say i was impressed the Coquito coffee had blends the creamy, coconut-rich flavors, its was so good 👍. Will order it again not to sweet just right 😋 . And to make my experience great i ordered her homemade guava and cheese Quesitos flaky puff pastry wrapped around a sweet, creamy filling. So delicious 😋 So if you are ever in the middletown area COME out and support your local business. Great customer service friendly environment makes me feel like I am in Puerto 🇵🇷 Rico with all the decor blends vibrant tropical colors (blues, greens, yellows) with natural materials like wood, featuring cultural symbols in the coffee ☕️ shop #puertoricancuisine🇵🇷 #puertorico🇵🇷 #puertoricocoffee #puertoricancoffee🇵🇷☕️"

"Was on my way to a destination an hour away when I spotted a Puerto Rican bakery just 15 minutes off my route — they had me at “pressed pan de agua sandwiches.” The area felt diverse and very clean, and while the café doesn’t have indoor seating, there are benches nearby where you can relax and enjoy your coffee. The owner was incredibly friendly and personable. I ordered a shaken espresso and a jamón y queso sandwich with mayo — both were chef’s kiss. I’m full and slightly upset I didn’t order a large shaken espresso (I was warned, lol). So delicious. Definitely coming back whenever I’m in the area"

"This coffee shop is such a gem! Kim, the owner, is one of the sweetest people I’ve met—I ended up spending an hour talking with her and it felt like catching up with an old friend. The drinks and food are to die for, and she even made me a pumpkin drink (I don’t even like pumpkin) that completely won me over. The personal touch she brings makes the whole experience so special. Highly recommend stopping by, not just for the amazing coffee, but also for the warm and welcoming vibe Kim creates. 🩷"

"The original was adorable but the new location is perfection. If you like your coffee strong y from la isla - then this is your spot. Now with seating and the beautiful aromas of Cafe."