"My wife and I have been going to Toasted Buffalo in Clarence for a number of years and have been quite disappointed in the shrinking of the toast portion while keeping the prices the same. We have been reluctant to go to them for breakfast these past few times because we have seen how their portions have shrunk, they’re understaffed but incredibly overworked, and the menu has been uninspired despite having to spend nearly $40-$50 for 2 people. Don’t get me wrong the toast is high quality and tasty but the price and shrinking portions are a major deterrent. This will certainly impact our choice of breakfast places in the future!"

"Wow!!! The absolute best coffe and smoothie and toast/breakfast food I have ever had! What an absolute GEM I was brought to!! I want to start recommending but I would be listing the entire menu! Multiple trips and Multiple coffees from a delicious dirty chai to an iced shaken caramel extravaganza my friend chose to an absolutely delectable glowing green smoothie (will make sure thats the name because it's important and so so good!) And they just kept getting better! The toasts! I have to let the photos speak for themselves but I do want to say the staff there are so lovely and helpful and how much they care shows in what they bring to you with a smile. Can't wait to come back!!"

"Well, dang. As I write this review, it's 5:15 on a Saturday night. Toasted popped up in my suggestions on Yelp, and now I really want some dadgum Italian fruit toast from Toasted. That's gonna be breakfast tomorrow. Toasted makes the kind of food that you crave. I've gone with my girlfriends, and I've gone with friends who have brought their kids. Everyone always finds something they LOVE on the menu. Not just, "oh, this is good. I might order this again," but "O M G, BECKY. LOOK AT HER BRUNCH!" Coffee here is good, too. The only thing I really wish they'd do is bring back the flight. I think it was something on their menu ages ago (before I ever visited for the first time), and I like the idea of being able to try some of these others without having to commit to a breakfast I won't love as much as I love the Italian fruit toast. Seriously, it's the best thing since the sliced bread it's placed on! Thank you Buffalo Beauty for being a Foodie and for making that food be toast and for bringing it to Clarence and for having the Italian fruit toast and amazing coffee, too. *deep breath*"

"Delicious food and drinks. My coffee is always made perfectly and my food is always fresh and delicious! Atmosphere is quiet yet buzzing with energy. I love this place!"

"Have been here several times. Super cute inside and out, food and drinks are great, and staff is wonderful! Love supporting small businesses!"