"I stopped by Café Bewilderment today for the first time and it instantly became my new go-to spot. The atmosphere is beautiful and cozy, and really welcoming. I sat at the bar and asked the woman working there if it was okay to sit even if I wasn’t ordering alcohol, and she was so kind. She said, “Of course you can sit here! You don’t have to order food or coffee just stay as long as you like.” That immediately made me feel comfortable. I ordered a cardamom latte and a warmed lemon blueberry scone (around $14), and both were incredible. The coffee was smooth, the flavors were perfect and rich, and the scone was delicious. I stayed for about two and a half hours to finish some work and loved every minute. The staff were genuinely friendly and the vibes were amazing. I visit cafés often in both Toronto and Buffalo, and this one really stands out, the energy here just makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Can’t wait to come back and try their brunch menu!"

"Hidden gem of a cafe! Feels almost like a speakeasy. Not a super large space, but cool vibes and decor. Food is a bit on the pricier side for the quality, but the drinks are amazing!"

"Absolutely beautiful space here! The team here was hustling on a busy morning but still gave great warm welcoming service with really thoughtful recommendations! I would definitely recommend this amazing cafe and will absolutely be back!"

"​What a gem! This coffee house is an absolute must-visit. The ambiance is cozy and perfect for a relaxing atmosphere. I loved their creative menu, which features unique coffee and tea options alongside other truly delicious food/pastries. The quality and flavor of everything were exceptional!"

"I am a very avid cafe goer, I use the hobby of seeking out new interesting cafes and lattes as a way to get to see new parts of Buffalo or to get to know a city I am traveling in better, and of all the cafes I have been to in the world Cafe Bewilderment stands apart as a uniquely excellent experience every time! For starters, their lattes are frankly the best I've had bar none! Of the 4 I have had from here every single one came out perfectly tempted, the foam a perfect bouncy and light consistency, yet clearly defined and separate atop the coffee. They also have a wide variety of delicious and homemade syrups, with rotating seasonal flavors as well as truly delicious staples (the cardamom and the lavender are to die for). I genuinely cannot say enough great things about the service here! I have had a different person cash me out and a different person make my latte all 4 times I have been there and every single time my server is so kind and warm that I leave the interaction with a smile! Everyone has been so nice, personable, and welcoming! The atmosphere is yet another way Cafe Bewilderment stands out from most cafes I have been to. The Cafe is in the lower section of a small business complex, the aesthetic is a very whimsical yet calming blend of earthy plant life and artsy marble, creating a unique and bold, yet somehow also cozy feeling. I could seriously talk about how much I love this spot all day! I didn't even go into the food, which is also really tasty. Bravo to the owner and everyone who works there, and thank you so much for being the pieces that make up my favorite cafe I have ever been to!"