"This place has a great dark, smoky, cozy vibe decorated in deep rich colors and with ample super comfortable leather couches. The cocktail and cigar menus are both extensive, and there is a nice selection of appetizers and snacks. Sadly, despite the place being over half empty, service was almost non-existent. I waited 30 minutes after finishing my only drink for a waiter to return, but alas, no. Meanwhile he visited the ladies nearby 6-7 times in the same interval. After giving up and going to the bar for help, I explained I had been waiting 30 minutes (originally wanting a second drink, but at this point just wanting to leave) and the only response I got was "oh." No apology whatsoever. I don't why I was ignored after my first drink was delivered as I was polite to the staff, dressed appropriately, quiet, and didn't make any special requests."

"My friend and I went here for a cigar and drinks. The lounge was really cool. Lots of comfortable leather couches and chairs. The cocktails were delicious. The server recommended some great cigars for us. I look forward to going back!"

"If you're looking for the ultimate escape in downtown Indianapolis, look no further than Nicky Blaine's Cocktail Lounge. Tucked away beneath Monument Circle, this subterranean speakeasy-style gem feels like stepping into a classic Hollywood film—think Casablanca meets Mad Men, with a dash of retro Indy charm. From the moment you descend the stairs, you're enveloped in an intimate, dimly lit atmosphere that's pure elegance plush filled with leather couches in cozy yet spacious areas, perfect for a romantic date, catching up with friends, or unwinding after a show, dinner, or following a Colts game. Unlike loud nightclubs, here you can actually hear your conversation while savoring the vibe—soft jazz or Sinatra tunes often playing in the background. The cocktails are nothing short of masterful and the signature martinis are legendary. The bar is fully stocked with premium scotches, bourbons, and whiskeys, and the bartenders are true artists who offer spot-on recommendations. Pair your drink with something from their extensive cigar selection (one of the best in the city), and you've got perfection. It's the kind of place where locals and visitors alike feel like VIPs. Nicky Blaine's isn't just a bar; it's an Indianapolis institution, and it lives up to the hype as Indy's original retro cocktail lounge. This is a must-visit. I can't recommend it highly enough—I'll be back every time I'm in town!"

"Had a wonderful cocktail here with my brother! It’s got the best vibes and even better worker! Brian is a great and makes good recommendations and then a good cocktail. You can’t go wrong here. Highly recommend taking a date here or go out with friends if you want somewhere fancier and high class."

"I was traveling and found myself in Indy looking for a place to relax and enjoy a cigar. Since my preferred brand listed Nicky Blaines, and it was close to my hotel, off I ventured. Form entering the doors and going down the steps, I knew this was special. I felt like going into a speak easy or old classic lounge. Awesome bar, great leather couches to relax and enjoy a beverage and cigar. Personable staff and food food at a great price. I would absolutely return and bring friends."