"First time eating here and I am not disappointed staff was friendly noticed they knew a lot of customers by name the manager or owner was pleasant and had good energy the customer service was a 10 out of 10 got a breakfast sandwich and the understood every part of the assignment the bread didn't over power the sandwich bacon was cooked nicely and they wasn't stingy with it I love the fact it didn't feel like I was eating another I wish sandwich I wish I could taste more than bread I wish I it wasn't so dry and bland or I wish i never came here I will definitely be back here tho every chance I get to try other things in the menu"

"Cafe attached to a corporate building, I'm assuming a lot of corporate employees go there for lunch. I got the full size Club sandwich with the sausage soup and it was AMAZING. A good old hardy sandwich that was filling and just well-made. This made me feel happy and filled"

"My first visit to Cafe 251 and it was a very positive experience. Being from out of town, Cafe 251 was near our office and offered a quick lunch. The service was good and the Turkey & Swiss was excellent and there was too much food. I would recommend this place to anyone, with a great selection and plenty of options."

"This place used to be really good every time I came downtown I made a point to stop and get soup and salad their ranch dressing is now watered down doesn't even have any flavor to it the soup is watered down like water I'm really disappointed"

"Hands-down best hole-in-the-wall lunch spot in downtown Indy. Stumbled on it by chance and it's quick, friendly, and has some really filling wraps. One of my go-to's and will be for a while! Chipotle Chicken wrap is fantastic."