
What People Are Saying
from Google & Yelp"Just a hot day and fancy popsicles in a very chic location. Just the right combo! I tried the vegan POG passion fruit, orange and guava and the Strawberry Rhubarb. Both the flavors were so different and extremely flavorful. Each lick was a different taste and summery vibes all along. The store is spacious and the lines go pretty quick. I, for one found the price pretty accurate. Service was really good where the server took the time out to share the ingredients, that was helpful since I wanted vegan only."
"We had yummy popsicles from Nicey Treat! The work was also super nice and I loved talking with her about how she’s going to be teaching soon! I had the cookie butter and it was like icecream, and I think anyone would like it! Some of them are more Icey like popsicles but some are like icecream! Super yummy and lasts long! Also great prices!"
"Visited this place last year while traveling for business and it was great! This visit, I walked in and no one was at the front. I waited for 5-8 minutes. The girl comes to the front, gen z stares me with no apology and just a quiet awkward “hey”, and I just say “nevermind I’ve been waiting for 10 minutes.” It took me off guard how bad the customer service was. It wasn’t her fault as she was probably busy in the back. I was just hangry and annoyed. Hire more people or have a bell of some sorts."
"Good customer service 👍 tasty strawberry cream. The banana cream however did not taste like banana had a toffee/coffee flavor idk if they burned the cream when making it maybe."
"This place is almost never open when it says it is. I have been here at least 4 different times when it’s listed as open only to show up and it’s closed. The ice cream is otherwise good if you can be lucky enough to catch them when they decide to open"
"This is not my first time having Nicey ice cream but my first time at this location. This location is very clean and the atmosphere is great. If you wanted..."
Hours
Nearby Coffee Shops in Fishers