"I’ve gone to the same bakery my whole life… until Windmill Bakery and Gas Station opened — and now I’m officially converted. 🙌🍩 Their donuts are that good. Fresh, soft, insanely delicious, and made with so much care. Hands-down the best in Evansville. The fact that it’s family owned makes it even better. Everyone is warm, welcoming, and you can tell they genuinely love what they do. It’s the kind of place you look forward to stopping at, even when you don’t need gas. If you haven’t tried Windmill yet, go. Trust me — one donut and you’ll understand why I switched after a lifetime somewhere else. 🍩🔥⛽ *Also! Super sparkly bathrooms which is a big deal bc I'm very OCD. 🙂"

"Man, this place is so good. Their donuts are always super super fresh and i'm totally hooked on the tiger tails and the chocolate iced bigfoot donut (ITS ACTUALLY SHAPED LIKE A FOOT...WITH TOES) but i'm pretty basic. My fiance loves all of their cake donuts, cream filled long johns, the cruellers , etc etc. They have such a huge variety here and this staff is friendly too!! Whats not to love? ❤️ 🍩"

"Locals love and miss the infamous Honeyfluff Donuts. These are very close replacements. Just as good, if not better. This is the spot for old-school yeast donuts."

"We are so happy this place is back and so close to home. Genuinely the best donuts we’ve ever had. We came on a Sunday morning at 9 am and it was very busy but the case was fully stocked! Employees are very nice."

"The place is so busy and yet it’s very very clean!! The wait was worth it!! Those are the best tasting donuts in the tri state area!! I drive across town just to get these!!!"