"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ An Afternoon to Remember at Lucrezia’s From the moment we arrived at Lucrezia’s in Chesterton, we knew we were in for something special. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and our server, Christopher, elevated the entire experience with his attentiveness, friendly demeanor, and thoughtful recommendations. He struck the perfect balance of being present without ever hovering, which made our evening both relaxed and enjoyable. For dinner, we chose two standout pasta dishes: the Penne Pasta casserole with Bolognese sauce and the Rigatone with braised Italian sausage. Both were absolutely delicious—rich, hearty, and perfectly prepared, showcasing the rustic Italian flavors Lucrezia’s is known for. The pasta was cooked to perfection, the sauces deeply flavorful, and the portions generous without being overwhelming. Dessert was the perfect finale. The Limon cake was light, refreshing, and delicately sweet, while the cheesecake with raspberry purée was luxuriously creamy with just the right tartness to balance each bite. Paired with a smooth, aromatic amaretto coffee, it made for a memorable and indulgent finish. In short, Lucrezia’s delivered a flawless dining experience. Between Christopher’s outstanding service, the exceptional food, and the cozy ambiance, this was one of those meals that lingers in the memory. Highly recommended for anyone seeking authentic Italian fare and genuine hospitality in Chesterton."

"After a failed attempt to dine the previous day due to a wait, (I really shkuld have waited) we returned and were promptly seated at this small, cozy restaurant with available patio seating. The waitress provided excellent service throughout the meal. The bread was fresh and hot, and the bruschetta appetizer was bursting with flavor. The stuffed shells were exceptional, possibly the best ever, while the fettuccine with chicken was fresh and tasty. The penne casserole was perfectly cooked, loaded with cheese, and featured a flavorful meat sauce. The carrot cake was a delightful, foolproof dessert choice, rounding out a highly satisfying dining experience."

"Mine and my husband's first time here. We have both worked in the service industry in the past and I must say, the food, and the service was immaculate. The establishment was super clean and they refilled our drinks without us having to ask (which is huge to us.) The food was beautiful in regards to presentation and very flavorful. I had the chicken piccata and my husband had the short ribs (which was so tender!). Also, you get free bread and oil (the oil tasted so fresh!) I wish I could give more than 5 stars. Our server, Maureen, was excellent! Very welcoming and knew her menu. We would highly recommend! By far, the best Italian restaurant in the area, and we drove about 40 minutes to get here. Well worth the drive and we will definitely be back!"

"Great place, food was delicious. Service was great, bartender was especially on his game. He was listening to everyone actively. He had drinks out in record time and they were perfectly executed. I had the short rib with mushroom risotto which was fantastic. Price was also very reasonable for the quality of food. Would go back."

"Italian Spaghetti was excellent. Veal Meatballs were fine. Cucumber Tomato Onion Salad was great. Very good service. Vodka Tonic hit the spot. Lots of pasta, appetizers, salads, soup and entrees. Full bar menu. Outdoor seating available."