"Stopped here on a Sunday, and honestly, I’m mad at myself for discovering this place so late! I’ve passed by this shop multiple times on my way to RMNP, always assuming it was just another touristy pie stop. I couldn’t have been more wrong. Wow. Just wow. This is hands down one of the best pie shops I’ve ever tried. The shop was packed with customers, which now makes complete sense. There’s plenty of parking and lots of dining space, so even with the crowd, it didn’t feel overwhelming. The service was excellent—friendly and efficient. A lot of people were picking up already made pies to take home, which says a lot about how popular this place is. I tried the apple pocket pie, green chili pork pocket pie and coffee. The sweetness level was perfect, and the apple filling was just right. For the first time ever, I finished one pie and another in a single sitting! The savory green chili pork pocket pie was served hot, and the pork filling was amazing—flavorful and comforting. A late find, but definitely a favorite now. Can’t wait to come back and try all their pies!"

"Delicious pies, ciders, and more. A great place to buy gifts as well. They have jellies, jams, chocolate, honey, candy, and souvenirs. On a cold day, it's nice to dine in, have a hot pie, and a hot cider. We had the chicken pot pie and cherry cider. It can get busy and packed at peak times; they may be out of certain menu items even one hour before closing, so plan to stop by earlier."

"Not to be corny, but it was a cherry experience at the Colorado Cherry Company. 👌🏽🍒The bison pot pie and cherry berry pie were both incredible —fresh, flavorful, and totally worth the stop. We were told they were out of chicken and bison pot pies when we ordered, but the staff made fresh ones for us right away, and the wait (about 15–20 minutes) was no problem at all. I also tried the bison chili which was very good as well. I also loved that we could sample their juices, which made it easy to pick our favorites to take home. They have a huge selection to choose from, and everything feels homemade and high quality. If you’ve been thinking about going, I definitely recommend it!"

"Colorado Cherry Company is a fantastic stop with so many delicious food and drink options. The pies are an absolute must-try—rich, flavorful, and baked to perfection. The ice cream was also delicious, making it a great treat to enjoy on the spot. In addition to the sweets, they do have hot food available for purchase, which makes it more than just a dessert stop. I especially enjoyed the old-fashioned black cherry soda—it was refreshing and full of flavor. If you’re passing through Lyons, this place is definitely worth a visit!"

"This place is amazing, there pie's are delicious and they serve hot pies. The other locations have them frozen and you bake them at home. I'm not a pie fan but this ones are amazing, hot or the fruits. Try the bison pie and the bison chilli soup and you would fall in love. Very friendly staff. It would be amazing if the other facilities have hot food and dine in area like the Lyons facility. Highly recommended 👌"