"This place was fantastic! My boyfriend and I both ordered a sandwich with a side but could have shared a sandwich; they’re huge. I got the chicken picnic with everything on it and pasta salad. The pasta was very flavorful. The only thing I would recommend for the sandwich is some seasoning on it. My boyfriend got the #1 melt minus lettuce and tomatoes with the chicken and wild rice soup. He said it was amazing. I definitely recommend this place but if it’s a first date don’t get the chicken picnic, it was bigger than my mouth.🤣"

"Based upon very positive Google Reviews, we (Senior Couple vacationers) ensured we did not conclude our Rocky Mtn trip without visiting this Grand Ave location. We enjoyed a very large and delicious Papa Bino sandwich and a Cy's Chef Salad, which we both shared, and there was plenty. There is plenty of outdoor seating-some covered, and also some indoor seating. The Customer Service and motivation of the employees here was very positive. We Highly Recommend this location in Grand Lake for vacationers, folks passing by Grand Lake, and local Residents. Thank You."

"It's back open! This place has been hit and miss lately but it looks like they did a full revamp. Seating outside and some tables inside. Ordered the Roasted and Toasted. Husband got the pastrami yummy. The bread was squishy which my husband liked. I wasn't a fan. Overall, with the pasta salad it was okay."

"I am so glad to have stumbled upon this deli!! I had the Hardy Arty and added turkey—DELISH! My husband had The Option and said it tasted “healthy.” I want to return for the Papa Bino and Grand Ave! They got busy quickly so I know this must be a neighborhood favorite—justly so."

"Amazing service. The price is decent and the food is fantastic. My wife and I shared a sandwich, and I had a Butterut Squash Soup. The soup was so delicious that I got another one for dinner 🤓. I strongly recommend this restaurant. Congrats to the Cy’s Team."