"I would start off by emphasizing that their pickles really are the best 💚 They’re so delicious. We frequently order their sandwiches to-go using online ordering, which is perfect because we never have to wait. Their café drinks are always delicious, I love the turmeric latte with a shot of espresso. The egg salad Sammy (mary Edith) is to die for as well as their version of an Italian (hey mambo) 🥪🥖🤘🔥 they also have a freezer case with frozen entrées to go like lasagna and enchiladas that are uniquely amazing. Great staff. Have used them for their sandwich party platters multiple times and they always bang, people consistently asking where the sandwiches are from. I do recommend stopping in here for a sandwich and pickle. The latkes are delish too"

"If I could give this place six stars I would. Some of the best matzo ball soup I’ve had, the “Gucci lox bagel” was exceptional, and the various baked goods were great. Some of the legendary Jewish delis in Los Angeles in New York City could learn a few lessons from this place."

"Our first trip to Plosky’s while vacationing in Carbondale was a great one. The bagel was amazing (and very large!) and the staff was very kind. I wouldn’t hesitate to eat there again when we are in the area."

"Great Coffee- Cool Staff Atmosphere is very bottom of a hotel feel But some outside seating which is nice Local Customers are a little snooty and stand offish Bagels are $3 - probly some of the cheapest food you'll find in Carbondale I recommend the Egg Salt Bagel"

"When I decided that I was going to be moving to Carbondale and the Central Rockies from the culinary Mecca of Northern California, I definitely wasn't expecting a Jewish deli in my new city, and certainly not one steps away from my home. So you can imagine my pleasant surprise when I saw one through the window of my U-Haul two days ago upon my arrival. Why it took me two days to get here is a question I'll continue to ask myself because Plosky's delivers and more! From the friendly staff to the comfy atmosphere to the AMAZING culinary treats, I can safely say I've never had a deli quite like this anywhere I've lived, let alone in the middle of the mountains. While I haven't tried their bagels yet, they look awesome in the display case and I'm sure I'll be taking a half dozen home with me next time. Whether you're a local like me or dropping by on your way to Aspen/Snowmass, you're doing yourself a disservice if you don't stop by Plosky's for a bite to eat. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!"