"Crooked Cauldron is pure magic in apothecary form. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm energy, witchy vibes, and the smell of herbs, teas, and intention. The owners are super friendly and incredibly knowledgeable, clearly passionate about their craft and always excited to create new custom tea blends, tinctures, and remedies. They also carry a beautiful selection of locally made goods—crystals, jewelry, herbal goods, spell kits, art, and more. It’s a space that celebrates creativity, healing, and community in such a genuine way. Whether you’re a seasoned herbalist or just curious, the shop is welcoming, cozy, and a great place to simply hang out, sip a cup of tea, and explore. They even have a comfy tea nook where you can relax and soak in the good vibes. Truly one of my favorite stops in Buena Vista."

"I absolutely adore this place. The owner has incredible energy. Really warm and inviting. The tea house is very whimsical and magical. It has all kinds of amazing things to buy like beautiful creations from local artists like rare jewelry to handmade clothing. But of course, the major draw for me was the coffee. I got a Blue Morpheus Latte and it was incredible. Not only was it delicious and perfect for me, it was absolutely beautiful with swishes of white and blue. The owner is very imaginative and the prices are incredible. I love that she is making her establishment more fun with the addition of the floating candles from the great hall from Harry Potter. It seems like she is really supporting the community with art classes and the sound baths being held there. I wish I lived in the city because I would be back in a heartbeat. Thank you!!!"

"Tourists in the area! We had a phenomenal experience at the Crooked Cauldron. Owners couldn’t be more friendly and welcoming. It was a highlight of our trip. From coffee, teas, lattes-everything was delicious. Local crafters this place is a MUST see!!"

"My husband and I visited the shop yesterday morning. We were greeted very kindly by their loving and hospitable hound dog 🐕 as well as from the two lovely and knowledgeable owners! Lisa and her husband were able to help us with all of our questions, show us options for natural healing. They also made a lovely lavender rose lemonade that was top tier! Thank you so much for the hospitality, wise information, friendly and kind gestures! We will without a doubt be back to see you"

"Really great tea, coffee, and all sorts of fun goodies and souvenirs. Stopped by with some friends on our way back to Pueblo, they got "the best coffee of their lives" and I picked up some cute soaps and scented candles. We all got to pick a little card at the end with a message for us. Really great place with chill vibes! Also a very friendly dog lives here 🐕"